Microsoft spent four days bouncing mail from senders who did everything right. A newsletter-distribution vendor breach in Japan surfaced under five different brand names and counting. And two unrelated regulators landed consent-enforcement actions in the same week, for the exact same underlying failure: unsubscribe requests that didn't actually get honored. It's a lot. Let's get into it.
Deliverability & Authentication
Here's the number that should get your attention: zero. That's how many days Microsoft has given anyone a fix timeline for a bug that's been bouncing fully-authenticated mail since the night of Friday, Nov 6.
Admins started seeing Outlook.com, Hotmail, Live, and MSN reject mail with 550 5.7.1 Message rejected: Message lacks SPF/DKIM/DMARC Auth Records and 550 5.7.23 SPF-failure codes — from domains with valid, passing SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. Some of the rejected messages carried Microsoft's own auth headers reporting spf=pass, dkim=pass, compauth=pass and still bounced. Resending the identical message minutes later sometimes worked, no config change required. This wasn't limited to Microsoft's own infrastructure, either — senders on Google Workspace and Zoho got hit too.
As of Nov 9, a Microsoft support-forum moderator confirmed it as a "service degradation" under active engineering investigation — not a policy change, just broken. No fix timeline. Bounces were still happening at last check.
This is the worst kind of deliverability problem: random, un-auditable, and hitting people who did authentication exactly right. If you've seen unexplained Outlook/Hotmail bounces or spam-foldering since Nov 5–6, it's very likely this and not your config. Keep a support-ticket paper trail — NDRs, error codes, timestamps, sending IPs — because Microsoft is going to want it eventually, and "eventually" is doing a lot of work in that sentence right now.
Sources: Spam Resource, Windows Latest, mlq.ai, Computerworld, Neowin
Sponsored

Battle-Tested Email Infrastructure Used By the World's Largest Senders
When you choose GreenArrow, you aren’t just buying another product or service. You’re choosing an experienced partner who understands the industry and your place in it. We provide proven, battle-tested tools along with the expert guidance to implement them effectively.
Whether you need maximum control with GreenArrow Engine on-prem or a turnkey managed solution with GreenArrow CloudMTA, we’ve got a modern deployment option that fits your use case.
If you’re bootstrapping an email program from the ground up, undergoing rapid scaling, or migrating a mature operation from another vendor, we’ve done it before with customers just like you.
Learn More and Get a Free DemoSecurity & Anti-Abuse
Japanese email distribution vendor Arara disclosed a breach on Nov 2 touching roughly 77 million email addresses across nearly 380 corporate clients. SEGA confirmed on Nov 9 that 2,196,044 of its own newsletter-subscriber addresses — across 11 SEGA and SEGA Fave newsletters — were in that pile, along with distribution metadata for another 92,273 addresses. SEGA account credentials sat on a separate, unaffected system, for what little comfort that's worth.
SEGA isn't alone. MOS Burger lost 7.5 million addresses. Shochiku Multiplex Theatres lost 3.3 million. TKC lost 2.3 million. IIJmio lost roughly 1 million. Same vendor, same breach, different logos in the headline every few days.
This is the part worth sitting with: none of these brands did anything wrong. Their newsletter infrastructure was fine. Their vendor's wasn't. "Our ESP is fine" is only ever as true as the ESP's own security posture, and a single upstream breach can keep surfacing under unrelated brand names for weeks. If you use a third-party newsletter distribution vendor, this is the prompt for an internal check-in — not because your brand is on the list yet, but because the list isn't finished growing.
Sources: BleepingComputer, teiss, Automaton West
Regulatory & Compliance
Two unrelated consent-enforcement actions closed within days of each other, on two different continents, over the exact same failure pattern.
Canada's CRTC accepted a $500,000 CAD undertaking from Pizza Hut Canada over CASL violations running January 2025 through February 2026: emailing without opt-in, missing unsubscribe links, and failing to actually process unsubscribe requests. Pizza Hut also committed to auditing its third-party vendors going forward — a tell about where the real failure lived.
Australia's ACMA fined telco SpinTel A$653,400 for sending more than 32,000 marketing emails between July and September 2025 to former customers, some of whom hadn't been customers in over a decade. SpinTel argued a prior business relationship implied consent. ACMA rejected that argument outright, and the investigation also found SpinTel kept emailing people more than five days after they'd unsubscribed. SpinTel is now on a 3-year compliance-audit undertaking.
Different regulators, different continents, same two failure points: consent assumed from a stale relationship instead of actually obtained, and unsubscribe requests that didn't get honored end-to-end across every downstream vendor and list. If you haven't personally clicked "unsubscribe," confirmed the action, and verified every downstream system actually dropped the address recently, both of these cases are your prompt to do it this week, not eventually.
Sources: Spam Resource — Pizza Hut, ACMA — SpinTel, Tech Business News
p=reject on consumer mail, which is exactly why this week's false-positive bounces were so disruptive. Spam ResourceThat's the week. If something's wrong above, reply and tell me — I read every response.
— John
Two Sponsor Slots Left Before the New Year
TWIE is booked solid through early December — five sponsors, two months of inventory gone. But December 23 and December 30 are still open, and I'll be straight with you: holiday weeks are a tougher sell, so this one comes at a discount.
Lock in either date before November 25 and it's $225 instead of $300 — 25% off. Use code TWIE-HOLIDAY25 at checkout. First come, first served. Once they're gone, they're gone, and the next opening isn't until January.
This Week In Email — thisweekin.email
Subscribe to This Week in Email and get future issues delivered to your inbox.